Powerful Owls and a Council’s the duty to enquire into likely environmental impacts

Court of Appeal grants expert evidence in judicial review case.

 

The Fred Caterson Champions Inc. (the Champions), a groups of residents from The Hills Shire in Northwest Sydney have initiated action in the NSW Land and Environment Court in an effort to prevent the Hills Shire Council clearing bushland for sports fields and installing stadium lighting in the middle of Fred Caterson Reserve – a known breeding habitat for Powerful Owls.

The primary case is still awaiting judgment. One of the reasons for delay was the initial refusal of the Court to allow the Champions to file expert evidence on the presence of a breeding pair of owls in the Reserve and the extent of their habitat.

The initial Council Review of Environmental Factors (REF) did not acknowledge that either the works nor the larger area affected by lighting spill, might be foraging habitat for the breeding pair of Powerful Owls.  Birdlife Australia began keeping records of the owls breeding in 2011. Powerful Owls are listed threatened species in NSW.

Utilising the Infrastructure SEPP (which allows authorities to build sports fields and infrastructure without development consent) and Part 5 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (EPAA), Council conducted a REF and approved the works. 

The approval was dated 30 September 2024, however Council did not inform the public of that decision ( nor the elected Councillors) until June 2025. While the LEC has not been asked to adjudicate on the issue, a Council is required to publish a REF with a works value of over $5m on their website or the NSW Planning Portal. Presumably that means publishing the REF just after it was made rather than the 8.5 months The Hills Shire Council took.

At the time of the decision a local council was made was required Under Part 5 to take into account that matters that will affect, or are likely to affect the environment to the fullest extent possible (Section 5.5 of EPPA). Even though the EPAA has recently been watered down by the Minns Labor Government Section 5.5 still requires a council to examine and take into account matters affecting or likely to affect the environment by reason of that activity.

The word examine is key to the requirement for an authority which, having the privilege of utilising Part 5 (i.e. marking their own homework), to thoroughly examine matters likely to affect the environment. The performance of the duty is activity—based and one that is to be assessed in the context of whether the examination of the likely environmental impacts was legally reasonable; Natural Grass at Norman Griffiths Inc v Ku-ring-gai Council [2023] NSWLEC 84 (Natural Grass) at [48].

Uniform Civil Procedure Rule (UCPR) 31.19 requires a party to seek the permission of the court before introducing expert evidence. UCPR 31.17 empowers the Court to restrict expert evidence in proceedings to that which is reasonably required to resolve the proceedings.

Expert evidence which was not before the original decision maker is not usually permitted in judicial review proceedings.

In Fred Caterson Champions Inc. trading as Fred Caterson Champions v The Hills Shire Council trading as The Hills Shire Council [2025] NSWLEC 139 Justice Pritchard had found at [16] that the Expert Report on Powerful Owls was really a critique of the merits of the Council’s failure to find identify Powerful Owls onsite rather than an expert opinion on what enquiries ought to have been made. Pritchard J dismissed the Champions application to admit expert evidence.

In Fred Caterson Champions Inc t/as Fred Caterson Champions v The Hills Shire Council [2026] NSWCA 68 the Court of Appeal found:

In summary the Court of Appeal found there was evidence before the Council from observations of Birdlife Australia that there were a pair of resident breeding Powerful Owls in the Reserve and yet the Council had failed to enquire into the effects of the stadium lighting on the owls, and therefore the expert report of Dr Debus should be admitted.  

The Court of Appeal made orders for the expert evidence to be admitted to the substantive hearing  which would be resumed by the NSW Land and Environment Court.

The Court of Appeal judgment must be understood as not finding that the Hills Shire did not make all reasonable enquires when drafting and determining to approve the works. Rather the decision is restricted to the admission of expert evidence to the Land and Environment Court to assist it in determining whether the Council made adequate enquiries or not.

Those substantive hearings concluded on 8th September 2026 and the parties now await the decision of the Land and Environment Court.

 

James Ryan

6 November 2026

James RyanComment